Opening Analysis / Round 1 / Round 2 / Round 3 / Final

Round 1 Analysis
With Anaheim and Washington going down, there are numerous entries that might take a tumble in the standings next round. Overall, however, the main teams are still in the running and therefore most of the core of the pool is intact. The first round attrition rate of 22.8% of picks is higher than last year, but not unreasonable.

There are still 43 entries that did not lose any picks, and only two that lost everything.

After one round we have a three way tie in first between Alexander Di Battista, Dennis Clayton, and Jeff Brinston with all of them losing two players. It is not until five points back - in 19th - where we find two poolies who didn't lose anybody - David Minuk and Jamie Robichaud. Naturally, they are projected to lead the pool after round 2. See where you rank in the projections below.

Daniel Briere
Daniel Briere, leading the playoffs with 11 points, is also the top darkhorse pick.
Top players still alive
With Anaheim as the only legitimate upset and Washington the only other popular team to go down, the top-picked players in the pool are all still alive. The most popular player to be eliminated was Alexander Ovechkin, who was the seventh-ranked forward with 89 picks. His nine-point performance, however, appears to be worth the first-round flyer (no pun intended) taken by half the pool. Last year's risk was Sidney Crosby, who had five points for 57 picks (of 132 entries).

Anaheim players Getzlaf (51 picks), Selanne (31), Pronger (27), and Giguere (24) were the other mid-ranked players eliminated.


Briere best darkhorse pick
Daniel Briere led the Philadelphia Flyers to their first round victory and leads the league in playoff scoring with 11 points. So this year's Hindsight Award for the best darkhorse pick is Jim Dart, the only poolie to pick Briere. This is closely followed by Marni Berman, the only one to take Marty Turco. Turco's ten points gives him a second consecutive strong showing - last year when no one picked him he had 18 points on three shutouts and three wins, but lost the seven-game opening series against Vancouver.

Defense: try again
The top notch defensemen didn't perform up to expecatations in round one. The most popular defensemen picked up a few points and stayed alive, but the best performers were eliminated or were not picked by anybody. Phaneuf, Green, and Pronger are gone and Robidas, Brisebois, and Kronwall were ignored by poolies.

Goalie battle adds twist
Detroit's goaltending situation has added some interesting drama for 15 poolies who were split on who to take. Nine entries had Dominik Hasek who appeared to have the upper hand, winning the first two games and causing regrets among Chris Osgood fans. However when Nashville evened the series, the six who took Osgood got a pleasant surprise as Osgood not only took over the reins, but collected a shutout in the decisive game. Stay tuned as the two former Cup champions continue to battle it out.

The Smiths: How to share
Over the first nine years of the pool we had very few cases where two people took the same picks. This year with so many more entries there are more of these cases, plus one group of five. Strangely, it is the Rice Lake League of Champions who are caught up most often. After numerous pools (between Lord Stanley and Shoot for Gold) where the Smiths have brought home cash, they now apparently have a sharing spirit and want to split this year's winnings with others. Perennial contender George Smith is in the Fab Five, while Sean and Tim are tied with others - and Chris and sister-in-law Tracy are tied with each other. We'll chalk it up to corporate social responsibility.

Biggest bust
Detroit's goaltending situation has added some interesting drama for 15 poolies who were split on who to take. Nine entries had Dominik Hasek who appeared to have the upper hand, winning the first two games and causing regrets among Chris Osgood fans. However when Nashville evened the series, the six who took Osgood got a pleasant surprise as Osgood not only took over the reins, but collected a shutout in the decisive game. Stay tuned as the two former Cup champions continue to battle it out.

One entry disqualified
Keen standings watchers may have noticed that last place recently became #189 instead of #190. Unfortunately this year for the first time we have an individual who did not pay by the deadline and was disqualified. I didn't like to do it but rules are rules - and I need to make sure people pay early enough, before "choosing" not to pay if they realize they're not going to win. Thank you to the 189 who paid up and good luck the rest of the way! Grand prize: $1134. 2nd place: $567. 3rd: $189.

Biggest Bust
With few big names going down hard this year and with increased playoff scoring compared to the past, it gets harder to find major busts. This year there were a number of candidates for biggest bust - of the minor variety - including Jason Spezza and Dany Heatley (1 point, 12 picks each), and Marian Gaborik (1 point, 11 picks). But given the importance of goaltending in this pool, the award is given this year to Martin Brodeur, with one point for 11 poolies counting on him to do plenty more. Brodeur is the first player to be bestowed the award twice, the first being 2004 when he had one point for 20 picks out of 102 entries.
Biggest busts over the years: 2008 - Brodeur; 2007 - Kariya; 2006 - Lidstrom; 2004 - Brodeur; 2003 - Joseph; 2002 - Entire Flyers roster; 2001 - Yzerman; 2000 - Gonchar; 1999 - Yashin; 1998 - Holik.

Round 2 predictions
Ok I did not do so well with my first round predictions this year. After going 7 for 8 last year I've got a mediocre 4 for 8 record (1 of 4 in the West). My round 2 predictions: Colorado, San Jose, Pittsburgh, Montreal.

Team and Player Stats:
Top Players
Forwards Team Pts Picks
Daniel Briere PHI 11 1
Vaclav Prospal PHI 9 0
Jarome Iginla CGY 9 89
Alexander Ovechkin WAS 9 89
Ryane Clowe SAN 8 0
Mike Ribeiro DAL 8 2
Alexander Semin WAS 8 3
Jaromir Jagr NYR 8 19
Sidney Crosby PIT 8 124
Defense Team Pts Picks
Mike Green WAS 7 11
Dion Phaneuf CGY 7 8
Stephane Robidas DAL 6 0
       
Goalies Team Pts Picks
Carey Price MON 14 30
Martin Biron PHI 10 0
Marty Turco DAL 10 1
Teams
IN  Picks  Cups 
Detroit 360 43
Pittsburgh 353 15
San Jose 308 71
Montreal 210 23
NY Rangers 44 1
Colorado 22 0
Dallas 11 1
Philadelphia 6 0
OUT Picks Cups
Anaheim 160 23
Washington 120 2
Ottawa 30 4
Calgary 30 1
New Jersey 25 4
Minnesota 18 2
Nashville 3 0
Boston 1 0

Projected Round 2 Standings

Here are the projected scores and rankings for after round 2. The projection assumes (wrongly, of course) that the remaining players will produce in round 2 at the exact same rate as in round 1, so Daniel Briere would get another 11 points and Carey Price another two shutouts.

LOST=Players Lost in Round 1
IMP=Impact (pts. by lost players)
IMP%=Impact as % of total pts.

R1 Rank
Proj. Rank
Name
R2 Projection
R1 Pts.
Lost
IMP
IMP%
Cup
191David Minuk11256000.0%SAN
191Jamie Robichaud11256000.0%MON
303Michel Melanson11055000.0%MON
303Georgia Strachan11055000.0%SAN
465Kevin Hoey10854000.0%SAN
96Norrin Ripsman107581915.5%MON
196Gilles Duguay10756158.9%PIT
18Dennis Clayton1066021423.3%ANA
528Jerome R. Brouard10653000.0%DET
528Gaston Nowlan10653000.0%SAN
528Barrett Boitson10653000.0%MON
528Sean Smith10653000.0%DET
528Kyle Hogg10653000.0%SAN
528Keith Chappell10653000.0%SAN
528Marcel Strachan10653000.0%SAN
1416Mike O'Brien105571915.8%PIT
1416Hank Shannon105571915.8%MON
1416Ava Raine Beder105571915.8%SAN
6519Peter Sadlier-Brown10452000.0%SAN
6519David Lester10452000.0%SAN
1419Shad Passmore1045721017.5%SAN
119Jeff Brinston1046021626.7%SAN
419Mouli Ramani1045921423.7%MON
1924Jen Reilly103561916.1%SAN
1924Sam Kern103561916.1%SAN
1924Bobby Pomerleau103561916.1%MON
1924Jerry Rynda103561916.1%SAN
1924Brian Lewis103561916.1%SAN
1924Harris Beder103561916.1%SAN
6524Einar Gainforth-Beech10352111.9%PIT
7331Terry Hoey10251000.0%SAN
7331George Smith10251000.0%SAN
7331Julian Vardy10251000.0%SAN
7331Mark Fahey10251000.0%SAN
7331Jeff Williams10251000.0%DET
7331Ron Wener10251000.0%DET
7331Russell Reed10251000.0%SAN
7331Duncan Campbell10251000.0%PIT
7331Jonas Struthers10251000.0%DET
7331Vincent Galante10251000.0%SAN
931Kevin Clarke1025821424.1%SAN
7331Antony Stais10251000.0%MON
7331Gary Compton10251000.0%SAN
131Alexander Di Battista1026021830.0%MON
7331Wayne Wood10251000.0%SAN
431Cheryl Wallace1025921627.1%MON
3047Karen Savoie101551916.4%PIT
3047Aron Slipacoff101551916.4%PIT
3047Gabe Pretto101551916.4%SAN
3047Ford Hatchett101551916.4%DET
3047Mitch Hatchett101551916.4%SAN
3047Andy Hotson101551916.4%SAN
1447Patrick Bouchard1015721322.8%DET
3047Mike De Petrillo101551916.4%SAN
9155Brendan Browne10050000.0%DET
9155Jay Dart10050000.0%DET
455Grace Yu1005921830.5%MON
9155Joel Pollock10050000.0%SAN
3055Jason Bartlett1005521018.2%MON
4660Ryan Slack99541916.7%DET
4660Jean-Pierre Reilly99541916.7%SAN
4660Aaron Pretto99541916.7%PIT
4660Bryan Wood99541916.7%SAN
464Brenden Kennedy985932033.9%DET
10564Steve Sealy9849000.0%SAN
9164Grace DeSantis-Peragine9850124.0%SAN
10564Georgina Hubbard9849000.0%SAN
5268Puya Vakili-Zad97531917.0%PIT
4668David Hood975421120.4%PIT
5268Della Santin97532917.0%MON
11271Alan Eng9648000.0%DET
9171Daniel Wiseman9650148.0%DET
3071Shane Kozlowich965521425.5%DET
3071Mohan Krishnamoorthy965521425.5%SAN
7371Pette Chappell96512611.8%PIT
6576Patrick Mitchell95521917.3%SAN
3077Bo Chen945521629.1%DET
11977Alvin Gainforth9447000.0%SAN
11977Cavin Bennett9447000.0%SAN
11977Deric Chow9447000.0%SAN
977Marni Berman945832237.9%DAL
7382Judy Wood93512917.6%ANA
7382Ian Winsor93512917.6%SAN
7382Robert Struthers93511917.6%SAN
1982Renee Loubert935631933.9%ANA
11286Kevin Hinch9248148.3%SAN
3086Sophie Wexler925531832.7%MON
488Bill Dawkins915942745.8%PIT
9188Al Sibille91501918.0%SAN
11288Brad Hotson91481510.4%SAN
14091Tracy Smith9045000.0%SAN
14091John Upper9045000.0%SAN
14091Chris Smith9045000.0%SAN
14091Rica French9045000.0%SAN
9191Mike Walsh905021020.0%SAN
14091Jacques Lirette9045100.0%MON
5291Shawn Robichaud905331630.2%SAN
6591John Crossingham905221426.9%SAN
11991Johnny Bouchard9047148.5%SAN
105100Mary Sue Strickland89491918.4%DET
19100Corgan Rikkonen895632341.1%CGY
105100Blake Wood89492918.4%PIT
30100Camillo Cipriano895542138.2%SAN
65104Camilla Marion885231630.8%SAN
9104Joel Elash885842848.3%MON
65104Sam Fielding885221630.8%NYR
91107Jim Dart875031326.0%ANA
105107Adam Jamieson874921122.4%ANA
52107Sanjay Talwar875331935.8%DET
150107Paul Markowski8744112.3%MON
112107Dan Greenstein87481918.8%SAN
112112Allan Moeser864821020.8%PIT
154112Mike van Steendelaar8643100.0%SAN
91114Richard Gretzinger855031530.0%DET
91114Richard Rikkonen855021530.0%SAN
105114Lee McLeod854941326.5%MON
30114Samuel Wexler855542545.5%SAN
73118Abraham McAllister845121835.3%DET
112118Vince Brescia844831225.0%ANA
52118George Crothers845332241.5%SAN
159118Judah Gould8442000.0%DET
9118Sharon Boitson845843255.2%MON
119123Andrea Ford834731123.4%ANA
91123Colin Kennedy835041734.0%SAN
91125Chris Kelley825021836.0%PIT
140125Dan Salerno82452817.8%DET
154125Alex Walsh8243149.3%DET
140128Steven Kjellberg81451920.0%DET
119128Shadd Dales814731327.7%ANA
52128Angela Keenlyside815332547.2%DET
65128Jeff Drisdelle815242344.2%ANA
119128Azra Champsi814731327.7%ANA
131133Al Kostiuk804631226.1%SAN
131133Steve Kennedy804621226.1%SAN
159135Dave Dufour79421511.9%MON
150135Max-Zeb Jackaman-Slipacoff79443920.5%DET
91135Sarah Trusty795032142.0%SAN
131138Patrick Provost784631430.4%DET
91138Jeff Hammond785032244.0%SAN
131138Blair Miller784631430.4%ANA
140138Isa Boucher784531226.7%SAN
140138Sean Sargent784531226.7%PIT
159143Mandy Ng77423716.7%DET
180144Ashleigh Harrington7638000.0%DET
154144Craig Battle764321023.3%DET
119144Ryan Spencer764741838.3%SAN
131147Tim Smith754631737.0%ANA
131147Stuart Klein 754631737.0%ANA
119147Rhonda MacSporran754741940.4%DET
140150Altaf Champsi744531635.6%DET
119150Art French744742042.6%NJD
181150Lyn Gainforth7437000.0%DET
131150Becke Gainforth744641839.1%SAN
150150Matthew O'Rourke744441431.8%SAN
112155DianMarie Winsor734852347.9%NJD
131155Dwight Butler734641941.3%DET
159157Mike Newbauer724231228.6%ANA
119157Ryan Whittle724742246.8%DET
119157Andrea Dawkins724742246.8%DET
173157Jason Roy72393615.4%OTT
168161David Loop71402922.5%ANA
164162Andrew Ryan704131229.3%ANA
168163Candace Unterschute694031127.5%DET
164163Michael Patton694131331.7%DET
173163Emma Fielding69393923.1%MIN
173163Sandy Morrison69392923.1%DET
159163Mitch Wexler694241535.7%MIN
173168Angie Lockett683931025.6%MON
105168Brendan/Evan Hoey684953061.2%NJD
150168Susan Sinclair684442045.5%SAN
168171Lori Robinson674031332.5%DET
173172Tony Vanderdrift663931230.8%DET
154172Andrew Hamilton664352046.5%OTT
173172Lee Beech663931230.8%ANA
168175Steven Hawley644041640.0%ANA
164176Li Sang Tan634141946.3%ANA
173177Scott Strachan613961743.6%OTT
182178Marilyn Beaulieu583541234.3%DET
131178Roger D. Brouard584663473.9%ANA
182178Ken Shuter583531234.3%ANA
154181Paula Brinston574362967.4%WAS
184182Ted Kennedy483452058.8%OTT
186183Laura Wood453051550.0%ANA
189184Keith Beaulieu442741037.0%MON
185185Noah Pollock433161961.3%NJD
164186Pierre Gainforth Beech4141941100.0%WAS
168187Patrick Gill4040940100.0%ANA
186188Joy Smith373062376.7%MON
188189Carol Hatchett352952379.3%DET







Comments, questions, suggestions? E-mail Mitch.